Relational Aesthetics, a significant concept introduced by French curator and art theorist Nicolas Bourriaud in the 1990s, focuses on how art generates meaning through social interactions and the construction of interpersonal relationships, rather than relying solely on the physical artwork itself or the artist’s personal expression. Analyzing the Chinoiserie style from the perspective of Relational Aesthetics allows for a deeper exploration of how this artistic style generates meaning through cultural interaction and the construction of human connections, establishing a new aesthetic relationship between Eastern and Western cultures. This analysis not only emphasizes the material characteristics of Chinoiserie as an art style but also highlights the complex processes of social interaction and cultural exchange behind it.
The Product of Cultural Interaction
Chinoiserie, as a style that blends Eastern and Western elements, perfectly embodies the concept of “art as a social field of interaction” within Relational Aesthetics. This style is not merely a simple imitation of Chinese cultural elements by European artists but gradually took shape through cultural interactions between Europe and China. Through this interaction, Chinoiserie became a cross-cultural aesthetic space, reflecting the European imagination, understanding, and misconceptions of Eastern culture at the time.
In this process, Chinoiserie is not a static artwork but a dynamic result of the continuous interaction between European society and Chinese culture. This style is essentially a product of social relationships, reflecting the social, political, and economic dynamics of Europeans as they encountered, understood, and reinterpreted Chinese culture.
A Chinoiserie gold box in the V&A Museum inlaid with shell, mother-of-pearl, and ivory patterns. Image courtesy of V&A Museum
For example, this gold box in the V&A Museum, designed by Michel-Etienne Filassier and made in Paris between 1745-47, features Chinoiserie patterns crafted from shell, mother-of-pearl, and ivory inlays. “The design emphasizes the dynamic movement of curves in Chinoiserie, and although the motifs depict Chinese figures, the choice of materials reflects what was popular in the European market at the time.”Since the Baroque era, European society has frequently used gilded decorations, not only to highlight the luxurious nature of the objects but also to protect them from physical damage.
The Complexity of Cross-Cultural Relationships
The formation and spread of the Chinoiserie style reflect the complex cross-cultural relationship between Europe and China. From the perspective of Relational Aesthetics, this cross-cultural relationship is not a one-way cultural transplant or simple imitation but a dynamic cultural interaction filled with tension and contradictions. Europe’s imagination and misunderstandings of Chinese culture not only serve as the driving force behind the Chinoiserie style but also form an integral part of its aesthetic significance.
This cultural interaction not only influenced European art styles but also, to some extent, altered Europeans’ perceptions of Eastern culture. Therefore, Chinoiserie is not merely a visual art phenomenon; it also embodies the power dynamics and cultural flows within the relationship between East and West, which lies at the core of what Relational Aesthetics seeks to explore.
ChuCui Palace Dews on the Vines Brooch
Take, for example, the jewelry pioneer of modern Chinoiserie style, ChuCui Palace. Their brooch “Dews on the Vines” combines calla lilies and lilies—two flowers representing the West and East, respectively. The piece cleverly juxtaposes these two flowers to convey the classic East-West blend and cross-cultural characteristics of Chinoiserie. The natural curves derived from Eastern aesthetics are expressed through Western inlay techniques, highlighting the appreciation of Eastern aesthetics, nature, and the free expression of emotions.
In this piece, ChuCui Palace combines traditional Chinese gongbi painting with Western inlay techniques, using varying shades of green and yellow to create the shading effect typical of gongbi art. From the juxtaposition of Eastern and Western floral elements to the harmonious integration of themes and Chinese gongbi painting, alongside the skilled Western inlay techniques blended with Eastern aesthetics, this piece becomes a vivid expression of lyrical and elegant cross-cultural jewelry, enriched by the meticulous detail of traditional Chinese art.
Diverse Audience Participation
From the perspective of Relational Aesthetics, Chinoiserie is not only the creation of artists but also a process in which audiences and consumers participate in cultural construction. In the 18th century, European nobility and the middle class engaged in this cross-cultural exchange by purchasing and displaying Chinoiserie-style artworks. Their choices in home decor and fashion design were, in essence, expressions of recognition and engagement with cross-cultural relationships.
In this interaction, the audience was not a passive receiver but an active participant in the construction of the Chinoiserie style through the consumption and display of these artworks. This participation endowed Chinoiserie with richer social significance, making it an important element in the cultural relationships of European society at the time.
Chinoiserie Sculpture Group “Touch” at the V&A Museum, UK, image courtesy of V&A Museum
This sculpture group “Touch” at the V&A Museum is part of a series representing the “Five Senses.” These pieces were likely designed to be displayed on wall brackets or mantelpieces and were made by the Derby Porcelain Factory around 1752-55. On closer inspection, one can see that while the figures’ clothing and hats are styled in a Chinese manner, their facial features are distinctly European. This reflects the influence of European perspectives on the final presentation of Chinoiserie artworks and crafts, shaped by the audience’s and consumers’ passive or active “participation.”
The development of the Chinoiserie style in Europe was not merely an artistic phenomenon but also a product of cross-cultural exchange and social interaction. By blending Eastern and Western aesthetic elements, Chinoiserie became a complex medium reflecting Europe’s understanding and misunderstanding of Eastern culture. It embodied the shifting power dynamics of the time and showcased the diverse participation of European audiences in cultural consumption. The uniqueness of this style lies not only in its visual fusion but also in its evolution as a dynamic art form shaped by social relationships. Ultimately, Chinoiserie transcended mere decorative significance, becoming a significant symbol and historical witness of cross-cultural dialogue.
Reference:
